We have prepared this comparison between four of the most renowned brands for your convenience so you get a clear view which of them has what to offer.
Getting a good night’s sleep is extremely important for your overall mental and physical health and mattresses have a significant role to play here. According to research conducted in 2011 by the National Sleep Foundation, over 92% of people think that a comfortable mattress has a huge role to play in getting good sleep.
Many people carry on with their old mattress due lacking the budget, however, if purchasing a new mattress gets on top of your priority list then it can significantly lower your stress level as well. Check out this infographic below and see for yourself why you need a new mattress?
According to another study conducted in 2009, new mattress significantly contributes to lowering stress. In addition to that many people are allergic to bugs in the bed. Over 20 million Americans fall into this category, as per WebMD and CNN have reported that these bugs can seriously cause problems for the people with asthma.
We have prepared this roundup between four of the most renowned brands for your convenience so that you get a clear view that which of them has what to offer. Therefore, we have picked AmeriSleep, Casper, Loom & Leaf and GhostBed.
So let the comparison begin!
BRIEF INTRODUCTION OF THE BRANDS
AmeriSleep came into being back in 2007 with a sister company names Astrabeds that specializes in latex mattresses. The brand sales its mattresses through its website and four brick and mortar stores located in four cities in Arizona. AmeriSleep sells memory foam mattresses of five different models including AS1, AS2, AS3, AS4, and AS5. All of these models have different layers and densities.
Like the sound of Amerisleep mattress? Click Amerisleep Mattress to read our full review.
Casper Mattress Company came into being in 2013 and gained popularity among the masses rapidly because of its unique idea of ‘bed-in-a-box’. The company allowed the user to take their mattress home with them without hiring any delivery service. This idea enabled the company to gain fame and now after a short time span, it is one of the best companies in the mattress industry. It has two different memory foam options named The Essential and The Casper. The third one is a combination of foam and latex and is called The Wave.
You can learn more about materials and comfort levels in our in-depth overview of Casper Mattress.
Loom & Leaf also offers memory foam mattresses and it is a subsidiary of Saatva Mattress Company. The brand was established in 2015 and sells its mattresses through the website and both the parent and the subsidiary don’t operate any brick and mortar store. Loom & Leaf became popular due to its eco-friendly mattresses made of luxury memory foam. Saatva also sells latex mattresses under the brand name Zenhaven.
See our in-depth Loom & Leaf Mattress overview.
The company came into being back in 2001 with the name Nature’s Sleep and in 2015, the name changed to GhostBed. The company sells GhostBed which is memory foam and latex mattress and GhostBed Luxe which is gel-infused memory foam. The company doesn’t operate any brick and mortar stores and sells all its products online.
| BRAND | TWIN | TWIN XL | FULL | QUEEN | KING | CALIFORNIA KING |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AmeriSleep | $849 – $1799 | $899 – $1849 | $1049 – $1949 | $1199 – $2099 | $1399 – $2299 | $1399 – $2299 |
| Casper | $350 – $1000 | $400 – $1150 | $500 – $1650 | $600 – $1850 | $725 – $2250 | $725 – $2250 |
| Morphiis Mattress | $699 | $799 | $949 | $1,099 | $1,499 | $1,499 |
| GhostBed | $445 | $600 | $700 | $695 | $875 | $895 |
AmeriSleep
as the above table suggests, AmeriSleep is the most expensive brand in this roundup as it sells all mattress sizes at high price ranges as compared to the other three brands.
Casper
Casper offers different mattress at different prices therefore with Casper, you have better price options as compared to the other three. It is also one of the reasons why Casper is widely popular because people can by a model according to their budget
Loom & Leaf
L&L mattresses are competitively priced beds where a twin size costs $699 and a California King that costs $1500. If you have budget constraint but you don’t want to compromise of quality sleep as well then you should go for Loom & Leaf.
GhostBed
GhostBed
GhostBed has a huge price advantage over all other three brands with twin size selling at $445 and California King selling at $895.
| BRAND | FIRMNESS | THICKNESS | SUPPORT CORE | COMFORT LAYERS | COVER MATERIALS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AmeriSleep | 7.5 (Firm) to 3.5 (Soft) | 10-inch to 14-inch | Polyfoam 1.65 and 1.8 PCF | Memory Foam 4 PCF | Polyester 77%, Celliant 21%, Spandex 2% |
| Casper | 7.5 (Firm) to 4.5 (Medium Soft) | 8.5-inch to 11.5-inch | Polyfoam 1.8 PCF | Memory Foam 4 PCF, Polyfoam 2.5 PCF | Polyester 100% |
| Loom & Leaf | 5.5 (Medium Firm) | 12-inch | Polyfoam 1.6 and 1.8 PCF | Gel Memory Foam 5 PCF, Memory Foam 4 PCF | Organic Cotton 100% |
| GhostBed | 6 (Medium Firm) | 11-inch | Polyfoam 2 PCF | Gel Memory Foam 4 PCF , Aerated Synthetic Latex | Polyester 100% |
You may be like to know more about Top Rated Mattress Brands.
AmeriSleep
AmeriSleep offers its customers different firmness levels ranging from 3.5 to 7.5. It also comes with different thicknesses ranging from 10-inch to 14-inch. Its support core has 1.65 and 1.8 PCF Polyfoam while the comfort layer has 4 PCF memory foam. The cover material of AmeriSleep has 77% polyester, 21% Celliant and 2% spandex.
Casper
Casper doesn’t provide its customers with soft mattresses and the firmness level ranges between 4.5 and 7.5. Casper is also available in different thickness levels ranging from 8.5-inch to 11.5-inch. Its support core is made of 1.8 PCF Polyfoam while the comfort layer has 4 PCF memory foam with 2.5 PCF Polyfoam. The cover materials are made of 100% polyester.
Loom & Leaf
L&L mattresses come with a firmness rating of 5.5 which means that is medium firm. Its thickness is 12-inch and the support core is made of 1.6 and 1.8 PCF Polyfoam. The comfort layer is comprised of 5PCF gel memory foam and 4 PCF memory foam while the covers are made of 100% organic cotton to keep it breathable.
GhostBed
GhostBed offers firmness rating of 6 which is medium-firm and thickness of 11-inch. The support core comprises of 2 PCF Polyfoam while the comfort layer is made of 4 PCF gel memory foam and aerated synthetic Dunlop latex. The cover material is 100% polyester to provide you that relaxing feeling.
DELIVERY
| CRITERIA | AMERISLEEP | CASPER | LOOM & LEAF | GHOSTBED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Delivery charges | Delivery to the contiguous US is free and additional charges to any outside destinations | US & Canada free shipping | Starting from $99 | Free standard shipping to the contiguous US and $600 additional fee for Hawaii and Alaska |
| Destinations covered | All fifty American states, Canada and Mexico as well as select international destinations. | All fifty American states and Canada | The contiguous US and Canada | All fifty states of the US |
| Shipment technique | Bed-in-a-box, compressed and vacuum-sealed | Bed-in-a-box, compressed and vacuum-sealed | Bed-in-a-box, but neither compressed nor vacuum sealed | Bed-in-a-box, compressed and vacuum-sealed |
| Delivery time | 3 to 5 working days | 2 to 5 working days | Non-disclosed | Non-disclosed |
| Availability online | AmeriSleep website and Amazon website (selected models) | Casper website and Amazon website (only memory foam mattresses) | Loom & Leaf website and Amazon website | GhostBed website and Amazon website |
| Courier | FedEx | UPS Ground | Company's own delivery service | FedEx |
| White-Glove services | None | Yes (in-home assembling and packaging disposal for $100) | Yes (in-home assembling and packaging disposal for $99) | None |
| Old mattress removal services | None | Yes ($50) | Yes ($39) | None |
TRIAL
| Length of the sleep trial | 100 nights | 100 nights | 120 nights | 101 nights |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mandatory break-in | 30 nights | None | None | 30 nights |
| Return fee | No fee | No fee | The original shipping fee will be deducted | No fee |
| Possibility of exchanges | After 30 nights | None | Yes ($99) | None |
| The full trial period for Amazon customers | No (30-night free trial) | Yes | No (75-night sleep trial) | No (30-night sleep trial) |
WARRANTY
| Length of warranty | 25 years | 10 years | 15 years | 20 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coverage on the non-prorated basis | 10 years | 10 years | 2 years (13 years prorated) | 10 years (10 years prorated basis) |
| Prorated fee | 50% of the original price | None (entirely non-prorated) | $99 and 25% of the original price in 3 to 5 years, 50% of the price in 6 to 10 years and 75% of the price in 11 to 15 years. | 50% of the original price and 5% per year after purchase |
| Transportation costs for repairs | The company will bear the expense during non prorated period but in the prorated period it will be the responsibility of the customer. | The company will bear transportation when the mattress is sent for the repair while the customer will bear the expense when receiving the mattress. | $99 | Mattress owners are responsible for the expenses |
| Depth of indentation | ¾-inch | 1-inch | 5.5-inch | 1-inch |
AmeriSleep
AmeriSleep provides free of cost delivery to the customers in the contiguous US while minor additional charges are applicable for all other detractions. The mattress will be sent to your doorstep vacuum sealed and compressed in a box and the delivery will take three to five working days through FedEx. However, the company doesn’t provide old mattress removal or white glove services to its customers. In addition to that, they also offer the customer with 100 nights of sleep trial with a 25-year warranty.
Casper
Casper provides free of cost shipping to all its customers in the US and Canada but doesn’t cater to overseas customers. The mattress will be sent to your doorstep, compressed in a box and vacuum sealed. The delivery will take two to five working days through UPS Ground. You can also avail white-glove service for $100 and old mattress removal service for $50. Furthermore, Casper provides 100 nights of sleep trial and 10-year warranty to its customers.
Loom & Leaf
The delivery services are provided at different rates according to the shipping destinations and the fees start at $99. The shipping services are available for the customers of Canada and the contiguous US. L&L will send the mattress in a box but it won’t be vacuum-sealed or compressed. You can also avail white-glove service for $99 and old mattress removal service for $39. Moreover, L&L provides a 15-year warranty and 120 nights of sleep trial to its customers.
GhostBed
GhostBed provides free of cost shipping to the customers in the contiguous US while $600 will be charged for deliveries in Hawaii and Alaska. The bed will be delivered compressed in a box and vacuum sealed through FedEx. However, GhostBed doesn’t offer old mattress removal service or white-glove service to its customers. Furthermore, GhostBed provides a 20-year warranty and 101-night sleep trial to its customers.
DELIVERY
| CATEGORY | AMERISLEEP | CASPER | LOOM & LEAF | GHOSTBED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall satisfaction of customers | 74% | 72% | 71% | 79% |
| Longevity and durability | Fair | Fair | Good | Good |
| Motion transferability | Very Good | Good | Excellent | Good |
| Sex | Fair to Good | Fair to Good | Fair | Fair |
| Conformance | Good | Fair to Good | Very Good | Good |
| Heat retention | Fair | Good | Fair | Fair |
| Off-gassing | Good | Fair to Good | Fair | Very Good |
| Noise | Excellent | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent |
| Edge support | Poor | Poor to Fair | Poor | Fair |
| Maneuverability | Fair | Good | Good | Very Good |
SLEEPER'S SLEEPING POSITION
| CATEGORY | AMERISLEEP | CASPER | LOOM & LEAF | GHOSTBED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Side | Fair | Very Good | Very Good | Fair |
| Back | Very Good | Good | Good | Good |
| Stomach | Good | Fair | Fair | Very Good |
SLEEPER'S BODY WEIGHT
| CATEGORY | AMERISLEEP | CASPER | LOOM & LEAF | GHOSTBED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lightweight (<130 lbs) | Fair | Very Good | Good | Very Good |
| Average weight (between 130 lbs and 230 lbs) | Good | Good | Very Good | Good |
| Heavyweight (>230 lbs) | Very Good | Fair | Fair | Good |
GhostBed
GhostBed turns out to be the winner of this roundup with a comprehensive lead over its competition and an overall satisfaction rating of 79%. It has shown good results associated with durability, motion isolation, conformance, off-gassing, and maneuverability. Nevertheless, it does have some issues concerning edge support and heat retention. It is best suited for lightweight stomach sleepers.
AmeriSleep
AmeriSleep gets the second spot when we talk about overall customer satisfaction with 74% rating. The rating is slightly on the low side when it comes to durability, heat retention and edge support. However, it is very good in off-gassing, conformance, and motion isolation. AmeriSleep is also highly recommended for heavyweight back sleepers.
Casper
Casper falls on the third spot just behind AmeriSleep and just ahead of Loom & Leaf with 72% overall customer satisfaction rating. The performance of Casper mattresses is on the low side when we talk about conformance, edge support, off-gassing, and durability. However, these mattresses are very good in terms of heat retention, motion isolation, and maneuverability. Casper mattresses are very good for lightweight side sleepers.
Loom & Leaf
L&L takes the last spot in this roundup with 71% overall customer satisfaction rating, just behind Casper. This mattress shows positive results regarding durability, motion isolation, conformance, and maneuverability. However, the mattress lags behind edge support, off-gassing and heat retention. Loom & Leaf is best suited for middleweight side sleepers.
You may be interested in How to choose a Mattress Fit for You?
Conclusion
GhostBed is leading this roundup by far which proves that the company has plenty of experience under its belt and it is utilizing that expertise to get ahead of the competition. As per our research, we do have a clear winner but the other three brands also have their unique traits. In the end, you must make a buying decision based on your own preferences and requirements.
Maybe you want a new one because your old mattress has worn down or because it is not the right type of mattress for you or maybe you sleep hot or want motion isolation. Whatever, the reason is you must understand the fact that a mattress can impact your sleep.
There are plenty of options available but you need to pick one of them by scanning its characteristics that would go well with your needs. In addition to that, you must also consider the after-sales service that is offered by the brands as well including trial periods, guarantees, warranties or delivery services. All these attributes have a significant role to play in the overall success of a mattress.
If in case you have any queries or suggestions then you can contact us by dropping a comment in given space below.
Happy Shopping!
